It was supposed to be a dream vacation for Natalee Holloway when she and her high school classmates took a trip to Aruba. Instead, when Natalee disappeared after a night out with her friends, it became a tragedy that made headline news. With the focus of the world turned on Aruba, three suspects quickly emerged. But authorities were faced with conflicting accounts, fruitless searches, and a dearth of physical evidence. Natalee Holloway had simply vanished. The three men have remained under a veil of suspicion, but the case has reached a standstill. Now, two years later, our team of unconventional investigators heads to Aruba to take a fresh look at the case that captivated a nation, and try to answer the question, what happened to Natalee Holloway?